Skip to content

Rental Listings Spotlight: January 2026 in Bay Terrace, NY

The Allstar Team
Rental Listings Spotlight: January 2026 in Bay Terrace, NY

Rental Listings Spotlight: January 2026 in Bay Terrace, NY

This January 2026, Bay Terrace, NY continues to present renters and landlords with a dynamic set of options, even as aggregate rental statistics remain limited. Rental trends are best evaluated at the listing level, where real-time facts shape decisions about price, features, and availability. If you are seeking affordable homes in Bay Terrace, NY this January 2026, or planning your next rental investment, take note—most data is granular, and every detail counts.

The Allstar Team reviews individual rental opportunities and tracks distinct features. January 2026 rental listings included a renovated 2-bedroom with modern kitchen appliances for $2,750 per month leased in just 15 days, and a 3-bedroom apartment at $3,100 featuring gym and parking, leased in only 12 days. Another 2-bedroom rental was offered at $2,400, demonstrating accessible price points for a range of needs. These specifics serve as your clearest benchmark—why it matters for renters and landlords is that timing and strong amenities affect both rental speed and comfort.

From Questions to Keys in Bay Terrace, NY

Set up a quick call with The Allstar Team to review local listings in January 2026. Even without aggregate stats, we provide clarity and personalized next steps.

(516) 580-5320 | Browse Bay Terrace, NY listings

Spotlight on January 2026 Rental Properties in Bay Terrace, NY

While aggregate metrics like vacancy rates and average market rent are not reflected in January 2026 data, the diversity of available apartments provides targeted choices. Individual listings show that amenities drive demand: properties offering renovations, parking, or gym access lease faster and at premium rates. Each new rental is an opportunity in a market that moves quickly.

With the typical 2-bedroom and 3-bedroom units offering monthly rents from $2,400 to $3,100, renters can benchmark opportunities depending on needs and budget. Landlords can see the advantages in equipping and marketing units competitively. The Allstar Team helps you find and evaluate active listings for best fit and speed to lease.

Why January 2026 Rental Listings Matter

In Bay Terrace, NY, specific features set listings apart. A unit's days on market—12 or 15 in these cases—signal responsive demand. Renters planning ahead should connect for live updates, while landlords are reminded to highlight amenities for optimal results.

Navigating Rental Transactions Efficiently

Although no average or median rental rate is available for January, The Allstar Team can guide you to properties aligned with lifestyle and price expectations. Whether you are looking for your next apartment or evaluating investment property, real-world listing data is the best resource.

  • No aggregate rent stats reported this month
  • 2-bedroom ranges: $2,400 - $2,750 (15 days to lease)
  • 3-bedroom with amenities: $3,100 (12 days to lease)
  • Modernized units and features lease rapidly

Explore the current rental landscape in Bay Terrace, NY, and let The Allstar Team match you to your ideal next home or investment based on up-to-date information and guidance this January 2026.

Your Search Starts Here

Search, compare and select from homes, condos, land for sale, and more! Save your searches and favorite properties for later review, get email updates of new listings, price reductions, and even schedule your property showings online.


What's My Home Worth?

Looking to sell your home? You can count on a quick sale with the best price, terms, and conditions possible while getting maximum listing exposure across multiple sources. Get your Free Home Valuation now!


We're proud to partner with leading real estate service providers. Please take a moment to explore our sponsors, whose support helps us bring you valuable market insights and tools.