Islip, NY Market Update for December 2025: Property Trends to Watch

If you have been eyeing Islip, NY for your next move, now is the time to dig into what December 2025 brings to the table. Are you curious about how recent numbers stack up for buyers, sellers, and renters in the local market? This analysis explores what matters most for each group, based on recent statistics and on-the-ground activity throughout Islip, NY.

As the median sale price stands at $575,000, a 3.0 percent increase year over year, buyers in Islip, NY face a market of growing property values. Why does this matter? Appreciation continues, highlighting market stability and the importance of timely decision making for buyers. With 256 active listings and a 2.2 month supply, the balance of supply and demand points to a moderately competitive landscape. These numbers mean that while options exist, acting fast is key for those seeking affordable homes in Islip, NY this December 2025.

Inventory and Pricing Insights Across Islip, NY

Sellers may be encouraged by the current list to sale price ratio of 98 percent, signaling that negotiations often close very close to asking price. For sellers, this dynamic answers the question: how to sell your house fast in Islip, NY? Accurate pricing and professional presentation dramatically improve outcomes when buyers are motivated. Meanwhile, new listings reached 106 for the month—an invitation for those entering the market to gain visibility.

Closed sales totaled 88 units, with average days on market settling at 45. This stat is vital for both buyers, who must be ready to act, and sellers, who can expect consistent traction for well positioned properties. Considering an average price per square foot of $355, buyers gain insights into the kind of value neighborhoods deliver, while sellers can benchmark how their home may perform.

Key Stats for December 2025 in Islip, NY

Month by Month Activity

Pending sales for December settled at 80, down slightly in line with the season, but reflecting resilient buyer demand. This number is essential for buyers weighing the question, is it a good time to buy in Islip, NY? For many, stability in closing activity is a reassuring sign, and supply continues to support both new and move-up buyers.

Rental Market Context in December 2025

For those considering leasing, the market paints a picture through individual examples rather than aggregate data. A 2-bedroom rental lists at $2,800 and a 3-bedroom at $3,350, both sitting on the market for over 20 days. Why does this matter? These prices and durations allow renters to benchmark available options in Islip, NY, though everyone should remember that broader market data is not available, so quick decisions and attention to detail are vital.

List of Must Know Metrics for Islip, NY December 2025

Median sale price: $575,000
Closed sales: 88
Active listings: 256
Average days on market: 45
Months supply: 2.2
List to sale price ratio: 98 percent
New listings: 106
Pending sales: 80
Average price per sq ft: $355
Mortgage rate (30yr fixed): 6.6 percent
Notable rentals: 2BR at $2,800, 3BR at $3,350

Getting Ready for Success: Market Takeaways

Understanding these core figures, you can position yourself to succeed in the Islip, NY property search. For buyers, market appreciation urges decisive action and strategic offers to capture value before prices climb further. Sellers benefit from low inventory and high closing ratios, but should emphasize accurate pricing and strong presentation to minimize days on market. Renters must pay close attention to listing details and be prepared, as rental options require prompt responses.

Plan With Confidence This December 2025

Speak with Anthony Robinson about timing, pricing, and neighborhoods that fit your goals this December 2025.

(305) 900-7270 | See local insights

Final Thoughts: The Path Forward

In summary, the December 2025 outlook for Islip, NY highlights the value of up to date metrics and responsive strategies for all clients. Every number matters—because it shapes your next chapter in this vibrant community. Connect with Anthony Robinson to maximize your strategy, whether you are entering as a buyer, seller, or renter. Stay aware of trends and act with clarity as you pursue your real estate goals this season.

Your Search Starts Here

Search, compare and select from homes, condos, land for sale, and more! Save your searches and favorite properties for later review, get email updates of new listings, price reductions, and even schedule your property showings online.

What's My Home Worth?

Looking to sell your home? You can count on a quick sale with the best price, terms, and conditions possible while getting maximum listing exposure across multiple sources. Get your Free Home Valuation now!