January 2026 in Bay Shore, NY: In-Depth Look at Inventory and Median Home Prices
Ready for a transparent look at the Bay Shore, NY housing market this January 2026? Both buyers and sellers benefit when a market offers clear numbers, steady options, and meaningful trends. Today’s inventory, median prices, and selling pace give you the tools to make smart moves.
Bay Shore, NY currently has 36 active listings, with 18 new homes joining the market this month. Buyers tracking affordable homes in Bay Shore, NY this January 2026 will find steady chances mixed with growing competition. The $565,000 median list price and $550,000 median sold price provide clarity on price expectations and fair negotiations for both sides.
Inventory and Market Pace in Bay Shore, NY: January 2026
Was this a fast-moving month? With an average of 38 days on market, homes are selling at a measured—but persistent—pace. Sellers take note: the 98.4 percent list-to-sale price ratio confirms that well-prepared properties attract near-asking offers. This is why knowing how to sell your house fast in Bay Shore, NY comes down to data-driven pricing and focused presentation within the current supply landscape.
Choosing a strategy gets easier when sales and inventory are in sync. January 2026 closed with 14 homes sold, helping anchor price discovery and market stability for everyone involved.
Market Fundamentals: January 2026 Takeaways
- 36 active listings currently available
- 18 new listings this month
- $565,000 median list price
- $550,000 median sold price
- 98.4 percent list-to-sale price ratio
- $325 per square foot average
- 38 average days on market
- 14 closed sales in January 2026
For those exploring is it a good time to buy in Bay Shore, NY?, these touchstones highlight relative stability. Sellers gain leverage, and buyers have a clearer sense of what to expect as they time their offers.
Expert Advice for Your Next Step
Sellers: focus on positioning your property near the $565,000 list median and ensure a professional presentation. Buyers: use the $325 per square foot benchmark and expect typical sales to land close to list price. Monitoring new inventory remains crucial for both sides.
Anthony Robinson’s Local Strategies for January 2026
Anthony Robinson advises clients to keep a pulse on list-to-sale performance and days on market to make informed, flexible decisions. These market factors matter now more than ever for positive, predictable outcomes.
Your Next Address Starts Here
Speak with Anthony Robinson about timing, pricing, and neighborhoods that fit your goals this January 2026. The right strategy gets you closer to your next address in Bay Shore, NY.
Rely on the insights and resources at Bay Shore, NY’s information hub to navigate this competitive January 2026 market with confidence and clarity.
Your Search Starts Here
Search, compare and select from homes, condos, land for sale, and more! Save your searches and favorite properties for later review, get email updates of new listings, price reductions, and even schedule your property showings online.
What's My Home Worth?
Looking to sell your home? You can count on a quick sale with the best price, terms, and conditions possible while getting maximum listing exposure across multiple sources. Get your Free Home Valuation now!