Amityville, NY Market Beginnings for January 2026: Key Numbers for Sellers and Buyers

Starting off January 2026, the Amityville, NY real estate market displays a lively blend of rising inventory and competitive sale prices, capturing the attention of both buyers and sellers. Are you evaluating the shifting seasonal momentum or considering if now is the right month to enter or exit the market? Let’s break down what these numbers mean for your move and decision making in Amityville, NY this January 2026.

For those keen on affordable homes in Amityville, NY this January 2026, the latest uptick to 44 active listings marks a notable 16 percent inventory gain, giving buyers more choices—critical in a market often favoring sellers. Why does it matter? More active listings ease competition, letting buyers evaluate a broader range of homes and potentially negotiate with greater confidence.

Key Metrics and Trends in Amityville, NY

Sellers achieved a median sale price of $540,000 in January 2026 with homes averaging 43 days on the market. This brisk pace is reinforced by a healthy 97.3 percent average list-to-sale ratio—meaning sellers are securing most of their asking price. For buyers, this strong seller position highlights the importance of preparation and readiness, as homes are moving quickly and discounts remain modest.

Distinct to January, there were 23 closed residential sales in Amityville, NY. With 1.9 months of inventory, the market skews toward sellers, suggesting ongoing buyer demand. Guidance for buyers and sellers in Amityville, NY becomes invaluable; when active listings are low, strategic pricing and timing can yield significantly improved results for sellers.

What Inventory Growth Means for Buyers

The expansion to 44 active listings gives buyers not just more choice, but also increases leverage—especially when paired with data showing 21 properties newly under contract last month. The average price per square foot climbed to $286, up 3 percent year over year. This signals healthy value appreciation and answers the question: is it a good time to buy in Amityville, NY? For many, the combination of increased options and competitive pricing makes this period highly appealing.

• Closed residential sales: 23
• Median sale price: $540,000
• Average days on market: 43
• List-to-sale price ratio: 97.3 percent
• Active listings: 44
• Months of inventory: 1.9
• Price per square foot: $286 (3 percent YoY increase)

Seller Strategies for January 2026

If you are considering how to sell your house fast in Amityville, NY, January’s data shows that attractive listing prices and market-ready homes are attracting offers within weeks. Sellers made an average concession of $2,700, mostly to cover buyer closing costs or minor property updates. Highlighting unique neighborhood advantages, like the 7 percent waterfront premium seen in south Amityville, can further optimize your net outcome.

Anthony Robinson believes tapping into the detailed monthly metrics—such as the high percentage of buyers using conventional financing (61 percent) and steady presence of cash buyers (21 percent)—shapes your sale strategy well. These facts build confidence for sellers in setting competitive prices while understanding what buyers are seeking most.

Action Steps as Amityville, NY Kicks Off the New Year

With first-time homebuyers representing 22 percent of January’s new escrows, the surge in market participation is meaningful. Inventory remains tight, but not so scarce as to limit buyers entirely. Consider focusing efforts on standout features, updating your list price with fresh comparables, or acting rapidly on homes near the waterfront if maximizing value is your focus.

January 2026 Insights and Opportunities

Buyers benefit from this month’s inventory growth, while sellers continue to capitalize on quick sales and high list-to-sale ratios. Whether buying or selling, January 2026 represents a time for informed decisions and decisive action in Amityville, NY.

• Check recent pricing for Amityville, NY property trends
• Compare value appreciation through updated comps
• Weigh purchase timing for waterfront versus inland locations

Navigating January 2026’s momentum is about using up to date data and tailored approaches in Amityville, NY. Whether you are searching for a home or considering a sale, having access to trusted guidance from Anthony Robinson can simplify your path to success.