Inventory Grows in Amityville, NY for January 2026: How Buyers Can Benefit

Are you watching for shifts in Amityville, NY’s real estate landscape as the new year picks up momentum? January 2026 marks a meaningful change, with inventory climbing and competition quietly evolving. Amityville, NY’s real estate market presents new options and leverage for buyers who are timing their entry this month.

With 44 active listings—a 16 percent increase in available homes—buyers in Amityville, NY this January 2026 finally enjoy more breathing room. This increase matters: when options expand, buyers gain power to compare homes, negotiate more confidently, and act with less pressure. Looking for affordable homes in Amityville, NY this January 2026? This could be your opportunity window, especially as the market previously leaned toward sellers for several months.

January 2026 Listing Growth: Impact on Opportunity

Sellers closed 23 deals last month, keeping pace with robust demand. However, the growth to 44 active listings shifts the pendulum, easing some urgency for buyers and prompting sellers to sharpen listings with competitive asking prices or highlighted features. The average days on market is 43, so even as buyers have more choices, quick action remains important.

For those entering the market, the median sale price of $540,000 continues to define expectations. A healthy 1.9 months of inventory—still seller friendly by national standards—suggests listing growth is not overwhelming demand, but does offer buyers room to compare properties and offers.

How Today’s Trends Shape Buyer Decisions

New listing growth means today’s buyers are less likely to face bidding wars, especially with the steady arrival of fresh homes. Does this mean it’s a good time to buy in Amityville, NY? With a price per square foot of $286 (up 3 percent year over year), forward looking buyers can benefit from stable value appreciation. Conventionally financed buyers make up 61 percent of closes, while 21 percent were cash—a nod to growing confidence and flexibility in the local marketplace.

• Active listings at 44 (16 percent higher)
• Robust buyer activity and steady demand
• Median price remains $540,000
• Time on market averages 43 days
• Price per square foot at $286, up 3 percent

Sellers: How to Sell Your House Fast in Amityville, NY

For sellers eyeing a swift move, the current inventory still leans toward your advantage with only 1.9 months of supply and list-to-sale ratios above 97 percent. That said, effective staging, accurate pricing, and highlighting property strengths—such as waterfront proximity with its 7 percent premium—help your listing stand out.

Anthony Robinson recommends leveraging data-backed guidance to navigate the rising choices available to buyers. This strategic edge means selling decisions are smarter and buyers can move confidently.

Maximizing Opportunity for Buyers in January 2026

With more listings comes a shift in negotiation dynamics. First-time homebuyers account for 22 percent of new escrows, and seller concessions like the $2,700 average offer extra incentive for decisive buyers. Focus on timely viewing, fully prepared offers, and guidance on property comparisons to maximize your results in Amityville, NY this January 2026.

Buyer Benefits in Focus This January

Buyers seeking expanded options in Amityville, NY should act now, leveraging the fresh market supply. Sellers too can win, but may face more discerning offers as buyers enjoy stronger negotiating positions this month.

• More inventory, less urgency
• Seller strategies: staging and market-correct pricing
• Advice for buyers: quick action on compelling listings

January 2026 is a time to act decisively, whether buying for the first time, seeking value growth, or adjusting your sale strategy in Amityville, NY.