Price per Square Foot Rises in Amityville, NY as 2026 Begins
Looking for the latest value signals as 2026 starts? Home prices in Amityville, NY are on the rise when measured by price per square foot. How does this impact buyers seeking affordable homes in Amityville, NY this January 2026 or sellers keen to maximize returns? Tracking this simple metric can help you map your next move with confidence.
In January 2026, Amityville, NY homes have reached an average price per square foot of $286, marking a 3 percent increase year over year. Why does it matter? For buyers, it means considering not just overall price but also the efficient use of space and lasting value—especially in a tight marketplace. For sellers, this trend supports strong asking prices and strategic renovations that boost perceived worth.
Understanding Today’s Price Metrics in Amityville, NY
With a median sale price holding at $540,000 and key metrics like the 97.3 percent list-to-sale price ratio, value growth appears steady. The average days on market remains at 43, reinforcing the need for buyers to prepare decisive offers and for sellers to present homes at their best.
Notably, value appreciation is not isolated—23 closed sales and 44 active listings ensure the competitive spirit of the market remains. First time homebuyers accounted for 22 percent of new escrows, a strong sign of broad appeal and accessible price stratification in Amityville, NY this January 2026.
Price per Square Foot: What It Means for Your Transaction
Rising values per square foot mean both buyers and sellers must pay attention to details. Sellers can justify competitive pricing, especially on move in ready or recently updated properties. Buyers evaluating how to sell your house fast in Amityville, NY or make a nimble purchase may want to focus on “hidden value” neighborhoods or features that stretch their dollar further.
- Average price per square foot: $286
- 3 percent year over year increase
- Median sale price: $540,000
- List-to-sale ratio: 97.3 percent
- Days on market: 43
Seller and Buyer Takeaways for January 2026
Anthony Robinson suggests layering price per square foot analysis with current comp reports to optimize either side of the transaction. Waterfront areas, showing a 7 percent premium, are especially appealing for those aiming for higher price points this month. Seller concessions averaging $2,700 continue to support buyers seeking the best overall value.
Strategic Use of Price per Square Foot Metrics
Is it a good time to buy in Amityville, NY? With price per square foot trending upward but inventory at 44 active listings and months of supply under two, acting quickly is recommended for both buyers and sellers this January 2026.
Key Considerations for the New Year
Tracking market value ensures you stay ahead in negotiations and investments. Whether your next move is listing, purchasing, or both, current price per square foot growth supports decisive action in Amityville, NY.
- Evaluate performance of updated listings
- Highlight efficient layouts and upgrades
- Use price per square foot data to guide strategies
Make the Market Work for You
Set up a quick call with Anthony Robinson to review comps and next steps tailored to you. Leverage January 2026’s pricing info in Amityville, NY for your best outcome.
Maximize results in Amityville, NY by pairing active market knowledge with your buying or selling plan this January 2026.
Your Search Starts Here
Search, compare and select from homes, condos, land for sale, and more! Save your searches and favorite properties for later review, get email updates of new listings, price reductions, and even schedule your property showings online.
What's My Home Worth?
Looking to sell your home? You can count on a quick sale with the best price, terms, and conditions possible while getting maximum listing exposure across multiple sources. Get your Free Home Valuation now!