Active Listings Climb in Amityville, NY: What January 2026 Means

The new year in Amityville, NY is bringing a wave of change as active real estate listings increase. What does this growth mean for local buyers and sellers in January 2026? It could alter the pace and strategy for anyone searching for affordable homes in Amityville, NY this January 2026 or listing a property soon.

This month, the active listing count is up to 44—a 16 percent jump providing buyers with more selection than they’ve seen in previous cycles. Why it matters: expanding options mean less pressure to rush, better negotiation potential, and a wider selection for comparison. However, the market remains swift, with the average days on market holding steady at 43 and a months-of-inventory figure of 1.9, still supporting a seller advantaged climate.

January 2026 Inventory Surge: Opportunity in Amityville, NY

With 23 homes closed recently and a median sale price of $540,000, plenty of movement is happening at all price levels. Increased listings give buyers new opportunities and sellers a reason to refine pricing or highlight property strengths. Sellers continue to see high list-to-sale ratios above 97 percent—homes that are prepared well still move quickly and at competitive prices.

In neighborhoods near the waterfront, properties see a notable 7 percent premium, further influencing pricing strategies for the month. For buyers prioritizing efficient use of funds, reviewing price per square foot—now at $286, up 3 percent year over year—offers insight into getting the most from each dollar spent in Amityville, NY this January 2026.

Predicting Buyer and Seller Activity

New inventory impacts both sides: sellers must pay close attention to comparables and market prep, while buyers can act with more confidence. For first time buyers, who comprised 22 percent of new escrows, adjusting offers ahead of the curve can be helpful. Anthony Robinson guides clients to adapt to these shifts, ensuring you’re ready to move when the timing’s right.

• 44 active listings: up 16 percent
• Median price: $540,000
• Days on market: 43
• 1.9 months of inventory
• List-to-sale ratio: 97.3 percent

Sellers: How to Sell Your House Fast in Amityville, NY

Compete by pricing smart, staging effectively, and working with up to date comps. Seller concessions average $2,700 in January 2026—a tool to smooth negotiations. Properties in high demand areas, especially by the waterfront, continue to be top performers.

Maximizing the Benefits of Higher Inventory

Is it a good time to buy in Amityville, NY? The growth in active listings and steady closed sales suggest buyers are in a stronger position this January, but should act promptly due to continuing high demand. Reviewing comps and touring new listings early can help secure the best matches.

Next Steps: Capture Opportunity in January 2026

January’s pace rewards proactive buyers and ready sellers. Leverage professional guidance and the most current stats to ensure your strategy matches the evolving conditions in Amityville, NY.

• Tour new listings as soon as they go live
• Reassess pricing strategies frequently
• Get pre-approved for faster transactions

Review your plans now and turn January 2026’s active market to your advantage in Amityville, NY.